Basketball South Africa executive fumble the ball
LIKE many in the South African basketball fraternity, I watched with great bewilderment on Friday as Basketball South Africa (BSA) made a comical and shoddy attempt to present their Annual Report and give feedback on their hosting of the FIBA U18 AfroBasket to the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Sports, Arts and Culture.
It was a disaster, to say the least, and probably set the game back. So the portfolio committee rightly had a field day – grilling and roasting the federation for what they offered.
Federation president Sanele Mthiyane and his secretary general Sibongile Fondini only succeeded in greeting and introducing themselves to the committee members. After the formalities, one elected official after the other tore into their sorry excuse for a report – leaving both men embarrassed.
Terms like incompetence, ineptitude, and out of their depth traversed my mind as the committee members highlighted the cacophony of errors in the report the secretary general tried to present.
It (the report) seriously lacked attention to detail. The poor numbering of pages drew the ire and laughter of committee members in attendance. Portfolio chairperson, Joseph McGluwa pointed out the lack of indicators and targets on the report to show BSA’s performance. There was no way of telling whether any performance targets had been reached. He noted that it was erroneous for Fondini to be the sole author of the report. “Under normal circumstances, a report of this nature is prepared by all assigned or by all members,” said McGluwa.
It turned into a masterclass on how not to run a federation. It seemed as if BSA was keen to present box-ticking exercises of events without providing sufficient scope of how they benefited or progressed South African basketball.
Aware that BSA was trying to pull a fast one, the Portfolio Committee duly blocked the attempt by BSA to proceed with their presentation.
Liam Jacobs, a portfolio committee member and former player, highlighted how BSA’s actions hindered basketball in the country. He was scathing in his assessment, given his attachment to basketball.
“This is what we call a generational fumble. In basketball terms, it is a fumble. This is a shame. It is completely wrong and if it goes on like this, South Africa is never gonna get its own Kobe Bryant. South Africa is never gonna get its own Michael Jordan. South Africa is never gonna get its own LeBron James. We will be stuck with the worst of the worst until Basketball South Africa gets its house in order. …Basketball has its own capacity to be part of Project 300. If we want to send more Olympians, we need to develop them in sports such as basketball. This is absolutely disgusting. It’s despicable. The report is airy-fairy. It’s wishy-washy,” said Jacobs.
The exasperated parliamentarians sent Mthiyane and Fondini packing, with the former offering a meagre apology. BSA was instructed to present itself to Parliament again and revise its report. The Department of Sports Arts and Culture was requested to accompany BSA on that visit.
Anyone who listened to the remarks lambasting BSA would have cause to run to the hilltops and shout for the BSA executive to resign. Whether that will happen is another thing, but they (BSA) can no longer fly under the radar.
It comes against the backdrop of the unorganised way BSA delivered the U18 AfroBasket, a tournament they had known about for over six months. The 11th-hour announcement of the South African men’s and women’s teams ahead of the tournament bordered on the ridiculous. In the end, the poor results from both teams were not surprising as there was zero preparation time.
Irked and disheartened by the losses of both teams, especially the women (who suffered heavy defeats), Samkelo Cele, one of South Africa’s finest talents, tweeted on X (formerly known as Twitter). “These are not “tough losses” these are embarrassing losses and something needs to change. This song has been sung over and over again. Can we actually start doing something about basketball in South Africa because I am tired of things being like this. CAN THE FEDERATION WORK?”
The scathing statements of the Portfolio Committee and Cele’s comment indicate that the national federation is irredeemable.
CAN THE FEDERATION WORK? It is a resounding Yes.
The basketball fraternity must select and elect the best among themselves. South Africa does not lack the intellectual, business and technical expertise to make basketball work. BSA can do with a dose of good fortune in leadership. If South Africa gets it right at the national level, this will have a cascading impact at all the other levels.
A change in leadership is only the beginning. BSA must run a capable office that coordinates and drives basketball activities in the country. A fit-for-purpose office should enhance BSA’s communication with its key stakeholders in the basketball fraternity. That office can leverage commercial opportunities to support those activities.
The Department of Sport Arts and Culture must support the federation’s revival.
That roadmap to recovery should include how districts and provinces can align to support the national program. Talent identification programs should be streamlined to support a common goal. Referees and technical officials should be capacitated to support the basketball program. Coaches should be empowered to maintain high standards in player development.
At a continental level, BSA must nurture a better working relationship with FIBA Africa. South Africa can benefit from the talent development programmes FIBA offers. An enhanced relationship with FIBA Africa will also be beneficial when South Africa hosts continental basketball tournaments.
South African basketball deserves better. BSA can do better.
Basketball South Africa executive fumble the ball Read More »